The difference in one sentence
A NAS stores and shares files. A server, besides that, runs programs: the business software, the user domain, virtual machines or a database. If you only need the first, a NAS is enough. If you need the second, today or two years from now, think about a server.
When a NAS is enough
In an office of up to ten or fifteen people sharing documents and making backups, a NAS with two or four drives does the job. It is quiet, uses little power and is managed from the browser.
Its limits appear when the number of people grows, when very large files are worked on over the network or when someone asks for it to “run the software too”.
When a server is needed
When there is business software with its database. When you want centralised users and permissions with a domain. When there are virtual machines. When drawings, video or heavy projects are edited directly over the network and 10 GbE is needed. Or when the company goes beyond fifteen people and folder permissions get complicated.
What almost nobody checks
ECC memory. It detects and corrects errors before they reach the drive. Many entry-level NAS units do not have it.
Snapshots. These are copies of the state of the folders every few hours. If ransomware encrypts the files, you go back to the previous snapshot in minutes. Ask for a file system that takes them.
Drives built to run all the time. Desktop drives are not made to spin 24 hours a day inside an enclosure with other drives.
The best option: the server and, separately, its backups
The combination that works best in a small or mid-sized company is a server to work on and a separate backup machine, which can be a NAS or a backup server. If the first fails or gets encrypted, the second has the data.
| Case | Machine | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Files and domain for 5 to 15 people | Office server, quiet tower | €1,612 |
| The same, in a rack cabinet with 4 bays | Office Rack server | €1,736 |
| Files, business software and virtual machines | SMB server, with ECC and 10 GbE | €4,234 |
| Backups for the whole company | Backup server, 16 TB usable and 8 bays | €3,457 |
Related hardware and guides
Frequently asked questions
Can a NAS act as a server?
The larger models run some applications and small virtual machines, but with little power and little memory. For business software with a database, a server gives far more headroom for a similar price.
And can a server act as a NAS?
Yes. A server shares folders just like a NAS, with per-user permissions and snapshots. What it adds is everything else: programs, domain and virtual machines.
How many drives do I need?
At least two, mirrored, so that one failing does not stop the office. For more capacity, four or more. And backups always on another machine.
Do I need 10 GbE?
Only if large files are worked on directly over the network, such as video, drawings or design projects. For office work, 1 or 2.5 GbE networking is enough.
Shall we size your server?
Tell us how many people you are, which software you use and how much data you hold. We will propose the server in writing, with a price, within 12 working hours.